2021 Vincent Girardin Puligny-Montrachet 1er Cru Les Combettes, Burgundy

The famous plot in 2021 because of the success in protecting the vines from frost when all around failed. The recipe was to light the bougies early and place them at double density, and replace if necessary during the night. This is really gorgeous. With a manged opulence, a perfect thread of mineral backbone, a finish that makes one salivate. A level of concentration over and above Perrières. Consider a 5th star – and say yes! Drink from 2026-2033. Tasted: October 2022.

93-96 points JM MW insideburgundy.com

A deft application of wood sets off the even more floral-suffused aromas of pear, apple, anise, exotic tea and a hint of orange peel. There is both excellent richness and vibrancy to the highly seductive and sophisticated medium weight flavors that flash the natural elegance of a topflight Puligny. Excellent. Drink 2029+ (June 23)  Outstanding

91-94 points Allen Meadows burghound.com